Saturday, March 30, 2013
The Symbol of the Easter Lily
Although I've always loved the beautiful Easter Lily, I've often wondered why and how it came to be associated with Easter. Yesterday, my wonderful friend, Melanie Wilkes, posted a picture of her dining table with a beautiful arrangement of Easter Lilies around a statue of an angel with a trumpet.
With regard to her personal love of the Easter Lily, she said, "The shut tight pod of the Easter lily could represent the grave. We wait and wait for it to open. Sometimes we get one that we think is never going to open!...and then it bursts open, almost when you aren't looking, like a trumpet heralding the opening of the grave. It's the loudest, happiest flower in nature."
What a beautiful image: the bud of the lily is a trumpet, that swells, and swells, then bursts open (ideally on Easter Morning) as a glorious trumpet heralding the opening of the tomb. As stated in Moses 6:63," ...ALL things have their likeness...All things bear record of me."
Doing some research online, I found the following description of the Easter Lily:
For many, the
beautiful trumpet-shaped white flowers symbolize purity, virtue, innocence,
hope and life—the spiritual essence of Easter.
History, mythology, literature, poetry and the
world of art are rife with stories and images that speak of the beauty and
majesty of the elegant white flowers. Often called the “white-robed apostles of
hope,” lilies were found growing in the Garden of Gethsemane after Christ’s
agony. Tradition has it that the beautiful white lilies sprung up where drops of
Christ’s sweat fell to the ground in his final hours of sorrow and deep
distress. Churches continue this tradition at Easter time by banking their
altars and surrounding their crosses with masses of Easter Lilies, to
commemorate the resurrection of Jesus Christ and hope of life everlasting.
A mark of purity and grace throughout the ages,
the regal white lily is a fitting symbol of the greater meaning of Easter.
Gracing millions of homes and churches, the flowers embody joy, hope and life.
Whether given as a gift or enjoyed in your own home, the Easter Lily, along
with other Easter blooms,
serves as a beautiful reminder that Easter is a time for rejoicing and
celebrating.
The following poem by Louise Lewin Matthews
captures the spiritual essence of the Easter lily:
Easter morn with lilies fair
Fills the church with perfumes rare,
As their clouds of incense rise,
Sweetest offerings to the skies.
Stately lilies pure and white
Flooding darkness with their light,
Bloom and sorrow drifts away,
On this holy hallow’d day.
Easter Lilies bending low
in the golden afterglow,
Bear a message from the sod
To the heavenly towers of God.
I was impressed by the symbolism of the Angel sounding his trumpet, as stated in D&C 45: 45 But before the arm of the Lord shall fall, an angel shall sound his trump, and the saints that have slept shall come forth to meet me in the cloud. I thought this would be a great tradition for our family to start, as well, so I went out looking for an Angel Statue today. I couldn't find an Angel statue with a trumpet, but I did find two beautiful pieces of art:
I am grateful for the knowledge that I have that my Redeemer lives, and that he is MY advocate with the Father, as described in D&C 45:3-5:
Listen to him who is the advocate with the Father, who is pleading your cause before him—Saying: Father, behold the sufferings and death of him who did no sin, in whom thou wast well pleased; behold the blood of thy Son which was shed, the blood of him whom thou gavest that thyself might be glorified;Wherefore, Father, spare these my brethren that believe on my name, that they may come unto me and have everlasting life.
These are the words of hope and love from our beloved Brother, the cause of our rejoicing.
Happy Easter!
Saturday, March 16, 2013
Just Some Thoughts on Homeschool Pros and Cons
I was just reading an article about homeschool pros and cons tonight. As I read through the comments on the article, I was actually shocked at how many hateful comments there were about home-schoolers, either directed at the parents (unfit to teach, or religious fanatic, etc) or the child (will turn out socially inept and unproductive). Wow. To me, homeschooling is about trying to find the best fit for each child.
It is rather crazy how many people think that children can only be taught effectively in a "public school" environment, when in actuality, public schools are, historically, a fairly new system. I would venture to say that the majority of people throughout history have been taught in their own homes, whether by a parent or by a hired teacher, or taught in a small group setting, (think Socrates "discussion groups"), or a one room school house (with one teacher teaching a variety of levels).
The point being, of course, that there are many methods that have been used successfully throughout history to gain an education, and just because one system has priority today does not mean that it is necessarily the best.
In Utah, parents currently have a huge choice of ways to educate their children. Public schools are one, but there are also charter schools, private schools, online schools, and homeschooling. Each of these options has many pros and cons. However, for me, the most important thing is that now-days, the choice doesn't have to be either/or. It can be a combination that takes the strengths of each. Of my 4 kids, 2 are full time in a charter school. One is mostly full-time in a charter school, but he does several classes online. One child is home-schooled full-time, but next year he will be part-time at home, and part-time in a regular public middle school. The great thing is, the public schools here are required to allow part-time students, so if you feel your child would do better being home-schooled in a subject, or doing it online, you have the flexibility to do that.
My middle schooler really struggles in math, so I've chosen to do that subject at home next year, where I can see where the gaps and problems are, and really hit it intensely. I also feel that certain subjects, like CTE are a waste of time, so I'm opting to do intensive writing classes at home during that time. At school, he will get to be with his friends and learn to follow a schedule. Also, he'll take classes there that I don't feel I can provide at home, such as science, choir, and keyboarding. In addition, having him in school part-time will give me some free time.
For my High schooler, charter schools are great, but often don't have as much diversity in class options as public schools, so by taking 2 courses online, he gets more options. In his case, he is able to take Japanese as his language, and slow down the pacing of his pre-calc to a level he can manage. With recently passes legislation in Utah, there are now many online high schools in Utah that offer up to two courses to students who are not enrolled full time in that school. This creates incredible flexibility to parents whose children struggle to succeed in the traditional school system, giving us the tools we need to help our children successfully complete their education in a well-rounded way.
I really love the way so many choices in Utah right now are allowing parents to navigate the pros and avoids the cons of the various options of schooling our children.
It is rather crazy how many people think that children can only be taught effectively in a "public school" environment, when in actuality, public schools are, historically, a fairly new system. I would venture to say that the majority of people throughout history have been taught in their own homes, whether by a parent or by a hired teacher, or taught in a small group setting, (think Socrates "discussion groups"), or a one room school house (with one teacher teaching a variety of levels).
The point being, of course, that there are many methods that have been used successfully throughout history to gain an education, and just because one system has priority today does not mean that it is necessarily the best.
In Utah, parents currently have a huge choice of ways to educate their children. Public schools are one, but there are also charter schools, private schools, online schools, and homeschooling. Each of these options has many pros and cons. However, for me, the most important thing is that now-days, the choice doesn't have to be either/or. It can be a combination that takes the strengths of each. Of my 4 kids, 2 are full time in a charter school. One is mostly full-time in a charter school, but he does several classes online. One child is home-schooled full-time, but next year he will be part-time at home, and part-time in a regular public middle school. The great thing is, the public schools here are required to allow part-time students, so if you feel your child would do better being home-schooled in a subject, or doing it online, you have the flexibility to do that.
My middle schooler really struggles in math, so I've chosen to do that subject at home next year, where I can see where the gaps and problems are, and really hit it intensely. I also feel that certain subjects, like CTE are a waste of time, so I'm opting to do intensive writing classes at home during that time. At school, he will get to be with his friends and learn to follow a schedule. Also, he'll take classes there that I don't feel I can provide at home, such as science, choir, and keyboarding. In addition, having him in school part-time will give me some free time.
For my High schooler, charter schools are great, but often don't have as much diversity in class options as public schools, so by taking 2 courses online, he gets more options. In his case, he is able to take Japanese as his language, and slow down the pacing of his pre-calc to a level he can manage. With recently passes legislation in Utah, there are now many online high schools in Utah that offer up to two courses to students who are not enrolled full time in that school. This creates incredible flexibility to parents whose children struggle to succeed in the traditional school system, giving us the tools we need to help our children successfully complete their education in a well-rounded way.
I really love the way so many choices in Utah right now are allowing parents to navigate the pros and avoids the cons of the various options of schooling our children.
Tuesday, March 5, 2013
Lorenzo Snow #4 Follow Up
Just a caution about using a video in your lessons: with the new YM/TW curriculum, teachers are using a lot more media in their lessons. ALL the YM/YW teachers wanted the TV! I was very lucky, and maybe a little pushy to be able to get one. Which means going into the lesson I was still trying to calm down from a little bit of panic, which is not the greatest state of mind to have before a lesson. The lesson ended up going really well, and the videos were well received, but still I never want to think end up on a Sunday without the bulk of my lesson. Bottom line: I will think long and hard before using a video in a lesson again!
Thursday, February 28, 2013
Lorenzo Snow Lesson 4: Strengthened By The Power of the Holy Ghost
In his first general conference address as President of the
Church, Lorenzo Snow taught, we are dependent upon the Spirit of the Lord to
aid us and to manifest to us from time to time what is necessary for us to
accomplish under the peculiar circumstances that may surround us.
The topic of the first video is The Light of Christ:
http://www.mormonchannel.org/video/mormon-messages?v=1737858982001
http://www.mormonchannel.org/video/mormon-messages?v=1737858984001
After the video, I've asked a sister to share an experience
(Rising Sun)
This past week, one day Makenzie was practicing her
piano. She had some new songs, and
she was having trouble with one of them.
After working on it for awhile, she asked me to come in and help
her. As I watched her try to play
the song, I could see immediately what the main problem was. The song was in Middle D position. Although Makenzie has learned to play
songs in several different keys, including Middle C, Middle D position is not
used often, and it was unfamiliar to her.
More importantly, it is so near to Middle C, that she kept shifting her
fingers to the more familiar keys.
I tried to explain to her what was happening, but she got so
worked up, she wouldn’t listen to what I was saying. Each time she would do it wrong, I would tell her to try
again, which made her angrier and angrier. Rather than trying to get it right, she just wanted to move
on to the next song.
As I lay in bed that night, I thought how similar that experience
was to the Holy Ghost in our lives.
Just like Makenzie, we make mistakes. Just like Makenzie, we need assistance .
Often, we recognize our mistakes, or challenges, and ask for
help. Often, however, we are so
intent on the problem that we can’t or won’t hear the answer, which may often
be a simple solution.
Just like Makenzie, there is someone available to help
us. Because of our baptism, every
Latter-day Saint can have the Holy Ghost as a friend to give counsel. We need the assistance of the Holy
Ghost as we endure trials, fulfill our duties, and prepare for Celestial glory.
President Snow said:
“We need assistance.
We are liable to do that which will lead us into trouble and darkness,
and those things which will not tend to our good, but with the assistance of
that comforter which the Lord has promised his Saints, if we are careful to
listen to its whisperings, and understand the nature of its language, we may
avoid much trouble and serious difficulty.”
Now, a lot of our problems we can and do, work out through
our own struggles. The very next
morning I heard Makenzie playing the song, and she had figured it out, but it
was not with out a lot of tears.
However, President Snow has a better answer:
We ought to understand, and I presume that we generally do,
that the work which we have come into this life to perform cannot be done to
the glory of God or to the satisfaction of ourselves merely by our own natural
intelligence. We are dependent upon
the Spirit of the Lord to aid us and to manifest to us from time to time what
is necessary for us to accomplish under the peculiar circumstances that may
surround us.
It would be simply foolish indeed to expect the Latter-day
Saints in these days to comply with the celestial law, with the law that
proceeds from God, and with his designs to elevate the people into his
presence, except they were sustained by a supernatural [heavenly] power. The
gospel promises this. It promises the gift of the Holy Ghost, which is divine
in its character, and which is not enjoyed by any other class of people, and
which we are told by the Saviour, should lead into all truth, and inspire those
who possessed it, and give them a knowledge of Jesus, a knowledge of the
Father, and of things pertaining to the celestial world; that it should inspire
those who possessed it with a knowledge of things to come, and things that were
past; and inspire them to an extent that they should enjoy supernatural gifts.
President Snow emphasizes:
“There are many important things required at our hands, and
many things which we can do, when assisted by the Spirit of the Lord,
which may at times seem almost
impossible to accomplish.”
Through the gift of the Holy Ghost, we are led to all truth
and strengthened in our faith.
President Snow said:
Persons come to me very
anxious to receive counsel upon some subject or other. They need not come to me
always, for the Spirit is within them to bring about good and to accomplish the
purposes of God. … It is not always necessary (to go to a church authority) to
get counsel; they have it within them; there is a friend that knows just
exactly what to say to them. From the time we receive the Gospel, go down into
the waters of baptism
and have hands laid upon us afterwards for the gift of the Holy Ghost, we have
a friend, if we do not drive it from us by doing wrong. That friend is the Holy
Spirit, the Holy Ghost, which partakes of the things of God and shows them unto
us. This is a grand means that the Lord has provided for us, that we may know
the light, and not be groveling continually in the dark.
Among the many associations with the Holy Ghost, one of the
most prominent is Light. On the
Mormon Channel website, Elder David A. Bednar presents a series of 3 video
clips entitled “Patterns of Light”, each focused on a different aspect or role
of the Holy Ghost.
After the video, I’ve asked a sister to share an experience
The topic of the second video is Discerning Light.
After the video, I've asked a sister to share an experience
The topic of the third video is The Spirit of
Revelation.
http://www.mormonchannel.org/video/mormon-messages?v=1737858986001
After the video, I've asked a sister to share the following story, and her thoughts:
(Light Switch)
In 1864, Elders Lorenzo Snow and Ezra T. Benson of the Quorum of the Twelve Apostles went on a mission to the Hawaiian Islands. They were accompanied by three other missionaries: Elders Joseph F. Smith, William Cluff, and Alma L. Smith. When their ship anchored off the coast of the island of Maui, all but Joseph F. Smith boarded a smaller boat to go ashore. As they approached the island, high waves struck, causing the steersman to lose control of the boat. The boat capsized, and all the occupants were thrown into the water. Soon everyone surfaced except Elder Snow. A group of islanders rushed to help, taking William Cluff and Alma L. Smith in a lifeboat to search for their friend. Elder Cluff related:
“The first I saw of Brother Snow was his hair floating upon the water around one end of the capsized boat. As soon as we got him into our boat, we told the boatmen to pull for the shore with all possible speed. His body was stiff, and life apparently extinct.
“Brother A. L. Smith and I were sitting side by side. We laid Brother Snow across our laps, and, on the way to shore, we quietly administered to him and asked the Lord to spare his life, that he might return to his family and home.
“On reaching the shore, we carried him a little way to some large barrels that were lying on the sandy beach. We laid him face downwards on one of them, and rolled him back and forth until we succeeded in getting the water he had swallowed out of him. …
“After working over him for some time, without any indications of returning life, the by-standers said that nothing more could be done for him. But we did not feel like giving him up, and still prayed and worked over him, with an assurance that the Lord would hear and answer our prayers.
“Finally we were impressed to place our mouth over his and make an effort to inflate his lungs, alternately blowing in and drawing out the air, imitating, as far as possible, the natural process of breathing. This we persevered in until we succeeded in inflating his lungs. After a little, we perceived very faint indications of returning life. A slight wink of the eye, which, until then, had been open and death-like, and a very faint rattle in the throat, were the first symptoms of returning vitality. These grew more and more distinct, until consciousness was fully restored.”
Looking back on this experience, Elder William Cluff knew why he and Elder Alma L. Smith were able to save Elder Snow’s life. “We did not only what was customary in such cases,” he said, “but also what the Spirit seemed to whisper to us.(Rising Sun)
Back in November, I shared with you how Keaton was having
such a struggle. I was so grateful
for the inspiration of the Spirit to keep him in his school. But then, of course, we still had to
deal with the issues. As I looked
for a solution, I can tell you
that I truly studied it out in my mind.
Based on the information, I tried to find what fit the symptoms. I looked at the possibility of drugs,
but immediately felt that was not it.
I went back and looked for patterns, I tried to determine if I could see
a starting point. Looking at it in
this way, I could see a clear 180˚ change immediately after he broke his
hand. He went from happy and
excited about school, friends and so on, to grouchy, poor grades, feeling down
and depressed. That’s when I
realized it was depression. I
remember having a clear impression in my mind of Post-surgical
depression.” I looked it up on the
computer, and knew what I would find—post surgical depression is a real
thing. We went to the Doctor, and
the Doctor agreed. He talked to
Keaton for a long time about how an injury affects males, especially teenagers. They can’t deal with the fact that they
are not invincible, and they get depressed. Just that visit was the turn around point, and now he is
just back to normal.
A sister will then share her thoughts on the Spirit of
Revelation.
I would like to close with these words by President Snow:
If we keep the light of the Spirit within us, we can so walk
in the gospel that we can measurably enjoy peace and happiness in this world;
and while we are traveling outward, striving for peace and happiness that lies
in our path, in the distance, we shall have a peace of mind that none can enjoy
but those who are filled with the Holy Spirit.
Sunday, February 24, 2013
Homeschool Language Arts
Next to math, Language Arts is the next big struggle with my 6th grader, who is not only dyslexic, but also has attention issues. Everything is a struggle for him academically, but much of that stems from his poor reading skills. Now, thanks to many years of determined tutors, he is reading pretty well. Not totally smoothly and fluently, but well enough for now. So, when I decided to pull him out in October, I knew it was time to work on some of the other weak area: spelling, writing, grammar. This is what we're trying:
Spelling: All About Spelling. When I read about this program from a homeschool review site, the advice was to start at Level 1, no matter what age your child was. For a 6th grader, that was going back quite a bit, but I did, and I'm glad. We started at Level 1 at the first of November, and finished Level 4 by Christmas by doing 4-6 lessons per day. We weren't doing a whole lot of other subjects, because I wanted the spelling up to grade level before we moved into writing. Now I am confident that we have filled in all the gaps, and we will be up to grade level (grade 6) on Friday!! This system has really worked for him--I can see a definite improvement in his spelling. When he does misspell a word, I can ask him to think about certain rules, and he can see the problem. This program uses a kinetic approach combined with phonograms. Each phonogram, including the alphabet, is printed on 1 inch plastic tiles, which you use to spell words. The vowel and consonant combination tiles replace individual letters as you spell out the words, so the student comes to see those as a single piece of the word. The system also includes key cards, with spelling rules on them, which you review until memorized. The system teaches how to break a word into syllables, and how that can help you determine the correct spelling. We're excited to get to Level 7 next year, which focuses on Latin and Greek roots. My 4th grade daughter is just starting this spelling program with her reading tutor at Level 1, and I'm excited to see how it helps her spelling.
Grammar: We've just finished First Language Lessons Level 3. In the reviews I've read about this grammar program, it had a lot of good reviews, but there were also many people who felt it was too boring and repetitive. It is VERY repetitive, and that is what has made it perfect for my son who struggles to learn. There is a lot of memorization, of poems and of the definitions of parts of speech. These are repeated over and over again throughout the year. The lessons are fully scripted, with teacher instruction and student response. This has been great to help my son retain the information. Like with AAS, we went through the material extra fast (3 lessons per day), to try to get him to grade level. After finishing FLL 3, I wasn't sure what to go with for grammar. I've used Rod and Staff, and liked it, but there is no workbook; the student has to write everything out on a separate notebook. Which is fine, but in his case, I thought it would be too time consuming and overwhelming since we are trying to accelerate through to grade level. In the end, I purchased FLL 4 and Growing With Grammar 5, because I didn't want to skip straight to Level 5 and leave gaps (since filling gaps is our whole focus this year). When I compared the programs, I found that I was able to integrate the two together, teaching similar lessons in succession. I used the FLL 4 as the spine, and inserted the corresponding GWG 5 lessons where they best fit. We will finish both FLL 4 and GWG 5 by the end of the year, and then do GWG 6 and 7 next year to get to grade level.
Writing: My son is great at writing fiction--especially now that he can spell. However, at all other types of writing, he really struggles. So, again, I decided to go back to square one. We are starting with Writing With Ease Level 1, by Susan Wise Bauer. I've looked at this program before, and to be honest, it seems so boring and tedious. The program includes copywork, dictation, listening and narration. However, I feel this repetitiveness, very thorough program is what he needs to become a good writer. We aren't going to do the full program, though. His handwriting is fine, so we won't do the copywork, and for now we are doing dictation in the spelling lessons. So, for the first two levels, we are just going to do every other week of lessons, the narration portion only. Not real excited about it, but I looked at SWB's writing program for his age level, Writing With Skill, and I know he won't be able to do it without the background of this preparatory program. Better to lay the foundation and excel later, than try to push it on him too early.
Vocabulary: We do Wordly Wise, Level 6. We're on lesson 6. It's too early to tell if he will retain any of it, but I can tell you he didn't retain a thing from the vocabulary he was doing at school, and he really enjoys the lessons, so it is a thumbs up from me!
Spelling: All About Spelling. When I read about this program from a homeschool review site, the advice was to start at Level 1, no matter what age your child was. For a 6th grader, that was going back quite a bit, but I did, and I'm glad. We started at Level 1 at the first of November, and finished Level 4 by Christmas by doing 4-6 lessons per day. We weren't doing a whole lot of other subjects, because I wanted the spelling up to grade level before we moved into writing. Now I am confident that we have filled in all the gaps, and we will be up to grade level (grade 6) on Friday!! This system has really worked for him--I can see a definite improvement in his spelling. When he does misspell a word, I can ask him to think about certain rules, and he can see the problem. This program uses a kinetic approach combined with phonograms. Each phonogram, including the alphabet, is printed on 1 inch plastic tiles, which you use to spell words. The vowel and consonant combination tiles replace individual letters as you spell out the words, so the student comes to see those as a single piece of the word. The system also includes key cards, with spelling rules on them, which you review until memorized. The system teaches how to break a word into syllables, and how that can help you determine the correct spelling. We're excited to get to Level 7 next year, which focuses on Latin and Greek roots. My 4th grade daughter is just starting this spelling program with her reading tutor at Level 1, and I'm excited to see how it helps her spelling.
Grammar: We've just finished First Language Lessons Level 3. In the reviews I've read about this grammar program, it had a lot of good reviews, but there were also many people who felt it was too boring and repetitive. It is VERY repetitive, and that is what has made it perfect for my son who struggles to learn. There is a lot of memorization, of poems and of the definitions of parts of speech. These are repeated over and over again throughout the year. The lessons are fully scripted, with teacher instruction and student response. This has been great to help my son retain the information. Like with AAS, we went through the material extra fast (3 lessons per day), to try to get him to grade level. After finishing FLL 3, I wasn't sure what to go with for grammar. I've used Rod and Staff, and liked it, but there is no workbook; the student has to write everything out on a separate notebook. Which is fine, but in his case, I thought it would be too time consuming and overwhelming since we are trying to accelerate through to grade level. In the end, I purchased FLL 4 and Growing With Grammar 5, because I didn't want to skip straight to Level 5 and leave gaps (since filling gaps is our whole focus this year). When I compared the programs, I found that I was able to integrate the two together, teaching similar lessons in succession. I used the FLL 4 as the spine, and inserted the corresponding GWG 5 lessons where they best fit. We will finish both FLL 4 and GWG 5 by the end of the year, and then do GWG 6 and 7 next year to get to grade level.
Writing: My son is great at writing fiction--especially now that he can spell. However, at all other types of writing, he really struggles. So, again, I decided to go back to square one. We are starting with Writing With Ease Level 1, by Susan Wise Bauer. I've looked at this program before, and to be honest, it seems so boring and tedious. The program includes copywork, dictation, listening and narration. However, I feel this repetitiveness, very thorough program is what he needs to become a good writer. We aren't going to do the full program, though. His handwriting is fine, so we won't do the copywork, and for now we are doing dictation in the spelling lessons. So, for the first two levels, we are just going to do every other week of lessons, the narration portion only. Not real excited about it, but I looked at SWB's writing program for his age level, Writing With Skill, and I know he won't be able to do it without the background of this preparatory program. Better to lay the foundation and excel later, than try to push it on him too early.
Vocabulary: We do Wordly Wise, Level 6. We're on lesson 6. It's too early to tell if he will retain any of it, but I can tell you he didn't retain a thing from the vocabulary he was doing at school, and he really enjoys the lessons, so it is a thumbs up from me!
Labels:
AAS,
all about spelling,
FLL,
growing with grammar,
homeschool,
Wordly Wise
Thursday, February 14, 2013
Homeschool Math Reviews: What I've used, what I like
If you are a homeschooler, trying to decide what math curriculum to use, I can sure relate to that. I have only one child (6th grade) homeschooling right now, but trying to decide what math curriculum to use has been a time-consuming challenge. Over the years, through various mutations of homeschooling, I've tried quite a variety of math curriculums with various success. These are some of the different ones we tried:
Saxon: My children have used this both at home and at school of and on for the past 9 years. It is a popular, solid program. Saxon uses a spiral approach, which teaches a concept on day and moves on to a different concept the next day. My son had been using Saxon at school for 4 years when I decided to pull him out. At that point he was a year behind and getting an F in math. Working with him at home, I could see that he has a lot of gaps, for example, time. My other kids (younger) are the same way. I don't think they are getting the concepts jumping from one to another, even though what they have learned previously is constantly reinforced in the lesson. Basically, I've gone back to square one with this child, and am trying to reinforce one concept at a time. I much preferred the lower levels with the consumable workbook and 25 or 100 fact sheets to the textbooks.
Math-U-See: We used this program for one year with all the children. It seems like a good program, but there seemed to be an overkill of repetitious problems in the exercises each day. It was too much, especially for my younger ones. I didn't like the Alpha, Beta, Gamma leveling-just tell me what the grade level is supposed to be!
Singapore: I loved the books and the low cost of this program. What I didn't like was having a text with the explanation and some exercises, and a separate workbook with additional problems. So, 4 small paperback books for each grade (3A Test and Workbook, 3B Test and Workbook) I prefer everything in one place. Also, the text and workbook are not made to be written in--you have to write the problems all out on separate paper. The program is cute, but moved to fast for my kids. They (particularly my 6th grader) need more explanation and review than this program. I wanted to love it, but it didn't work for me. Later on, I would be willing to look at this program again.
Miquon: I really adore this program. I just love its quirkiness and all the different exercises that you won't find in ANY other math program. This comes in 6 workbooks, (Red, Orange, Blue, Green, Yellow and Purple), with roughly 2 books for grades 1, 2, and 3. Each book teaches a variety of concepts, including starting multiplication and division in Level 1. There is a chart at the back of each book showing what concepts are taught in each book, assigned by letter. For example, addition is A, and Red may have A-1 through A-23, while Orange has A-24 through A-39, and Purple has no A section. This program uses cuisinaire rods. Even in 6th grade, these are challenging for my son.
Kumon: I got these workbooks at Target, although they do have Kumon math tutoring centers around. I liked them, but only as a supplement. A high proportion of the answer boxes have the answer shaded in, leaving too little of the remaining problems for the kids to figure out on their own.
Math Mammoth: I've only been doing this program for about 3 weeks or a little more, but there are so many things I like about it. First, they have a placement test online. That was very helpful. Second, there are such a variety of materials available. Light Blue series is a full curriculum from 1st to 5th. The Blue series are workbook of individual concepts, such as Addition, Clocks, Measuring, Money, Geometry. Some of these Blue series workbooks cover a range of levels, like from 1-3 or 4-6. After doing the diagnostic, my 6th son didn't pass the 3rd test! Rather than going clear back through the whole 3rd level, though, I was able to see where his weaknesses were, and just buy the concept workbooks for those, to fill the gaps, then we will more into the 4th Light Blue Text. There are two more series of workbooks, Gold and Green, which are supplement worksheets either by grade level or by concept. Just a very thorough program. One of my favorite things about this program is that there is so much emphasis on mental math. I'm so tired of seeing my children slug through all the borrowing and regrouping on their Saxon problems, when I can easily see the answer through simple mental math.
Can't wait to see it if really works.
Professor B: Just bought this one, it had great reviews. It is a VERY different approach, but I'm willing to try anything to help math click for my 6th grader. This would just be a supplement to MM
Life of Fred: I'm undecided on whether these books actually teach math, I just don't have enough experience with them to say. My 11th grader did LOF Algebra I, and was able to move into Geometry at school and do fine. My 3rd grader loves to just read them, but he doesn't do the "let's play" problems. There are only about 3-4 "problems" at the end of each chapter. I do like the way he presents the math concepts in a story. The things I love about it are the way he discusses so many other subjects, from history to art to economics in the story line along with the math. I also love that my kids will just read this on their own. My son has read the first 4 in the series at least 4 times each. This and Professor B might make a good solid math curriculum. The books are nice hard back, and about $16.00 each. The whole series for lower grades is about 14 books, so $240 or so for all. The next level books are more expensive.
You can see I'm a curriculum junky, especially when it comes to math, but I'm hoping I've found what I need in MM, LOF and Pro B. For now.
Saxon: My children have used this both at home and at school of and on for the past 9 years. It is a popular, solid program. Saxon uses a spiral approach, which teaches a concept on day and moves on to a different concept the next day. My son had been using Saxon at school for 4 years when I decided to pull him out. At that point he was a year behind and getting an F in math. Working with him at home, I could see that he has a lot of gaps, for example, time. My other kids (younger) are the same way. I don't think they are getting the concepts jumping from one to another, even though what they have learned previously is constantly reinforced in the lesson. Basically, I've gone back to square one with this child, and am trying to reinforce one concept at a time. I much preferred the lower levels with the consumable workbook and 25 or 100 fact sheets to the textbooks.
Math-U-See: We used this program for one year with all the children. It seems like a good program, but there seemed to be an overkill of repetitious problems in the exercises each day. It was too much, especially for my younger ones. I didn't like the Alpha, Beta, Gamma leveling-just tell me what the grade level is supposed to be!
Singapore: I loved the books and the low cost of this program. What I didn't like was having a text with the explanation and some exercises, and a separate workbook with additional problems. So, 4 small paperback books for each grade (3A Test and Workbook, 3B Test and Workbook) I prefer everything in one place. Also, the text and workbook are not made to be written in--you have to write the problems all out on separate paper. The program is cute, but moved to fast for my kids. They (particularly my 6th grader) need more explanation and review than this program. I wanted to love it, but it didn't work for me. Later on, I would be willing to look at this program again.
Miquon: I really adore this program. I just love its quirkiness and all the different exercises that you won't find in ANY other math program. This comes in 6 workbooks, (Red, Orange, Blue, Green, Yellow and Purple), with roughly 2 books for grades 1, 2, and 3. Each book teaches a variety of concepts, including starting multiplication and division in Level 1. There is a chart at the back of each book showing what concepts are taught in each book, assigned by letter. For example, addition is A, and Red may have A-1 through A-23, while Orange has A-24 through A-39, and Purple has no A section. This program uses cuisinaire rods. Even in 6th grade, these are challenging for my son.
Kumon: I got these workbooks at Target, although they do have Kumon math tutoring centers around. I liked them, but only as a supplement. A high proportion of the answer boxes have the answer shaded in, leaving too little of the remaining problems for the kids to figure out on their own.
Math Mammoth: I've only been doing this program for about 3 weeks or a little more, but there are so many things I like about it. First, they have a placement test online. That was very helpful. Second, there are such a variety of materials available. Light Blue series is a full curriculum from 1st to 5th. The Blue series are workbook of individual concepts, such as Addition, Clocks, Measuring, Money, Geometry. Some of these Blue series workbooks cover a range of levels, like from 1-3 or 4-6. After doing the diagnostic, my 6th son didn't pass the 3rd test! Rather than going clear back through the whole 3rd level, though, I was able to see where his weaknesses were, and just buy the concept workbooks for those, to fill the gaps, then we will more into the 4th Light Blue Text. There are two more series of workbooks, Gold and Green, which are supplement worksheets either by grade level or by concept. Just a very thorough program. One of my favorite things about this program is that there is so much emphasis on mental math. I'm so tired of seeing my children slug through all the borrowing and regrouping on their Saxon problems, when I can easily see the answer through simple mental math.
Can't wait to see it if really works.
Professor B: Just bought this one, it had great reviews. It is a VERY different approach, but I'm willing to try anything to help math click for my 6th grader. This would just be a supplement to MM
Life of Fred: I'm undecided on whether these books actually teach math, I just don't have enough experience with them to say. My 11th grader did LOF Algebra I, and was able to move into Geometry at school and do fine. My 3rd grader loves to just read them, but he doesn't do the "let's play" problems. There are only about 3-4 "problems" at the end of each chapter. I do like the way he presents the math concepts in a story. The things I love about it are the way he discusses so many other subjects, from history to art to economics in the story line along with the math. I also love that my kids will just read this on their own. My son has read the first 4 in the series at least 4 times each. This and Professor B might make a good solid math curriculum. The books are nice hard back, and about $16.00 each. The whole series for lower grades is about 14 books, so $240 or so for all. The next level books are more expensive.
You can see I'm a curriculum junky, especially when it comes to math, but I'm hoping I've found what I need in MM, LOF and Pro B. For now.
Labels:
homeschool,
Kumon,
math mammoth,
miquon,
MUS,
professor b,
Saxon,
singapore
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)




